Noah looks sideways at her at the question before he shakes his head in answer. That was the question no one could ever answer. His parents would just say that was the way that he was made and to accept it, to accept always being sick and he was tired of it so he made a choice.

"They could add to those books a list of all that the both of us did, which no one else should ever do under any circumstances," he says and then he shakes his head. He is not a fan of a boring life either, but at least a boring life doesn't result in a bunch of other people getting killed or hurt. He doesn't really have the right-

He turns to her now to look at her curiously. "...how did that happen? People do not die and then simply return." Unless there is something else going on.